Saturday, November 24, 2012

Post 2: Ballad of Birmingham

I can't wait to start the book and see what types of discussion will occur.  Keep in mind that if you have a gmail account, you can post with your email instead of going through Name/URL.  Name/URL is just the option for those of you who do not have an email address.

On another note, in class we discussed some background information about the Civil Rights Movement.  One of the points we discussed was the church bombing that occurred and influenced the writing of "The Ballad of Birmingham" which in turn influenced Christopher Paul Curtis to write the book.  I would like you to click on the link below and then click on The Story of the Bombing.  Read the story of the church bombing and then answer the discussion questions.  Remember, these are opinion questions so there are no right or wrong answers.

Here is the link: http://balladofbirmingham.org/

Discussion Questions:

1. What effects do you think the church bombing had on members of the Civil Rights Movement? (Those who were against segregation and for equal rights of African Americans and others)

2. How would you have responded to the bombing if you were in Birmingham at the time?  (Be specific!)

Please choose one question from above to answer in complete sentences.  Make sure you explain which question you are answering.  After answering the question, you must respond to 1 classmate.  In response to a classmate, you can post that you agree with them and WHY or expand on their view; don't just post that you agree or disagree because I will not count it for credit.  If you have any questions, please ask! Happy blogging! :)

154 comments:

  1. I am answering question #2 (how I would have responded) When I would hear about the bombing, I would first feel shocked and then sad that the girls died.
    After the arrest, I would want to sit in the court and listen to why Richard Chambliss bombed the church and did he know that 4 girls died. I would be disappointed at the judge for giving Richard Chambliss a $100 fine and 6 months in jail for having dynamite, but not sending him to prison for killing the girls.
    I would protest, like Martin Luther King Jr. did. I would hold signs, and let people know that this wasn't right. The girls did nothing wrong, but died because they went to church.
    Craig Richards

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that richard sould have been sent to prison for killing the girls

      Delete
    2. I agree because it was so sad for the little girls to die just because they went to church .

      Delete
    3. I agree because i think he should of went to prison for killing the girls

      Delete
    4. ya they did not need to die for gonig to church

      Delete
    5. i think that they died because it was there time

      Delete
    6. I agree that Richards should have gone to jail becasue of killing the girls, but I think he should have been sent to jail not just becasue of killing the girls but also because of not having a permit for the dinamite and he should have gotten a bigger fine.

      Delete
    7. church is supposed to be a safe place to things go wrong

      Delete
    8. i also think thats sad and why would he do that,i dont know,maybe no one will find out.

      Delete
    9. I agree because i think he should go to prison for killing the girls.

      Delete
  2. i would be sad family and friend could be hurt

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i would also its not fair that them kids died

      Delete
    2. me too. I really care about my family.

      Delete
    3. i agree because i dont want my famaly members hurt

      Delete
    4. i agree beauce it would be relly to lousu your parents and all of your friends =(

      Delete
    5. i agree because they didnt know that was coming

      Delete
  3. i would be so sad if one of my fmily members got bombed because of there skin tone . I think that it would be truley crule for someone to bomeb that church !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. I think that you shoudn't judge any person by there skin color. I think it's completly ironic how it used to be back then and the dramatic difference it is today. It is totally different! I would, as well, be terribly sad if one of MY family members die. It is crrrruellllll.

      Delete
    2. i agree because it can be mean and hurtful to others.

      Delete
    3. if i were at the bombing i would freak out like who wood bomb a church you might be able to be racist but bombing a church that is just taking it way to far my reaction to the bombing if i was there i would get all the help i could

      Delete
    4. I agree, because people shouldn't be treated differently just because of their skin color.

      Delete
    5. i agree to your statement id be crying if my parents died

      Delete
    6. Iwould be sad if my family was bombed because of skin color or disabilities.

      Delete
  4. I am answering question 2.When I heard about the bombing I was very shocked that someone would do that.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am answering question #2 (how i would respond to the boming of the church) I was shocked when the bombing accuried at the church. It's sad to hear that the girls died at a young age. It wasn't fare that he wasn't getting anything but a $100 dollar find and sent to jail for 6 months.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i was shoked two when i read that those girls it wasent fair for them girls they were at a young age that wasent fair

      Delete
    2. i agree. because he should of been sent to prision immeaduitly for life

      Delete
  6. if i were one of the people who were in the judges court i would protest them i would stand up and say NO no matter what thay did i think people shold think before thay do its like a sin. even though he did get in troble he should have gotton in more he should have goton 4 or 5 years in prison not because he had dinomight but cause he bomed a church killed 4 children and also hurt 14 people.But not only was it a sin but he did it in to hurt others

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yes i agree because i think that that was a sin too.

      Delete
    2. I think they shouldn't have gotten 3 or 4 years in prison but 10 years.

      Delete
  7. question #2 when i found out about the bombing i was mad and felt that those people should be put on Death Row and it effected alot of lives because of what those people should have not done that and they should feel the pain the children did cause it is not fair for them to hurt inisent kids like that if i was alive back then i would be in court and make sure they get put in jaill for what they did to the 4 kids and they did nothing expept go too church and died for no reason at all and those people will remeber what they did for the rest of there life and will be charged for it when they die

    ReplyDelete
  8. im answering question # 1 it effected them in a emotional way and also could have messed up the civil rights movement its self but maybe because of it it could have opened eyes of people that are for segregation and made them change sides

    ReplyDelete
  9. i am answering question # 2 (how i would have responed) when i hear about the bombing, i would first feel shocked about heraing the news and i would start crying and praying that thosre girls were alright. then i would go to that trial and say how dare you bomb those 4 inasent girls ''what did they do to you.'' i would be happy that he got arrested

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How would you feel that he only got 6 months in jail and had to pay $100?

      Delete
    2. I agree because I would be sad that the chruch and people died in the bombing.

      Delete
    3. i agree dead people is not cool!

      Delete
    4. How would you be happy i would be sad because it wasnt my falut it was someone else so it wouldnt be happy

      Delete
    5. yes , it would be very tradgic if something happend to people that tried to got to a place that they thought was safe .

      Delete
    6. i agree because it goes againts the moral code and laws of god

      Delete
  10. answering questin #1.. i think the way the poeple feel that are against segrogaysion it proplably was really hard for them because that was their towns church.

    ReplyDelete
  11. i am answering question #2. I would be made and if they saw the man put a box under the church then what im mad about was that they didnt investigate it. I am also very devistated.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with Andi. I was also be angry and sad if someone bombed my church, and no one would investigate it.

      Delete
  12. i am gonna answer #2{how i would have responded to the bombing}i would have been really scared i would have cried all my life after knowing that those things happened to those peaple

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree becasue knowing that people died because of there skin coloer

      Delete
  13. #2 i would feel very sad and suprised about the bombing.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I am answering #2.
    After hearing about what happend, i would be really scared and I probably wouldn't believe what happend. I would also be really sad. I would feel bad for all of the people who lost their family.
    I would be curious on why exactly Richard Chambliss bombed the church. It is kind of crazy he would do it at a church.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, it is disrespectful to God to bomb the church and just flat out crazy to do that. The church is a place of peace and not crazy people bombing innocents.

      Delete
    2. I agree, because when I commented I also said I wouldn't know/believe what's going on! And I would feel AWFUL for all the people that died and ALL of their family.

      Delete
  15. (number 2) i would have worked hard to catch the man that set the bomb there and get him arrested and serve his time in jail for the murders and the box of dynamite instead of being not guilty of murder and just being charged for a box of dynamite

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree because those kids didnt do anything to harm him yet he had to take their lives for no reason

      Delete
  16. questern 2 i will be terified because they did it at a church where people are being blessed by god and thats when 4 girls died at a church and that makes it more sad .Including their gardians would be sad and crying for their daughters and family

    ReplyDelete
  17. (#1) If I was in the Civil Rights Movement, I would be very angry and sad if I heard that a chuch got bombed. I can imagine that the people at the Civil Rights Movement were probably devistated and angry because of that act of the bomber being viciously mean.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Q2. I would be scared and I wouldnt want to live there anymore but i also would be dissapointed in the kkk.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i would be scared to and i wouldn't want to live there also

      Delete
    2. #2: Your right i would be scared but i would also be sad for someone bombing someplace that i live , and i would be teriffied and would probably move away

      Delete
    3. yes i very much agree because thats true

      Delete
  19. Question #2:
    The feelings I would have would be terror, sadness, and I would be worried. Terror because such a person would plant a bomb in such a place! Sadness because of the four girls killed, they didn't do anything wrong to deserve that. And worried because what if Richard Chambliss did it again? He was only given a fine of $100 and that doesn't seem enough.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree so much because, it really was a bad sin and only 100 is CRAZY!

      Delete
  20. im answering #2(how i would have reacted when ever i heard about the boming??
    I first would have felt scared,shocked,and worried.Then after the arrest i woud have wanted to know why he bomed the church.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree because it would be scary and shoking if that happend to us

      Delete
  21. i'm answering #2, i would have been very sad and scared. i feel sorry for those girls and their family.

    ReplyDelete
  22. #2: I would be really shocked that the some of the girls died.I would be really mad at the person who let off the bomb.If i was there i would protest that the people who let the bomb go off go to jail for a very long time.What he did was not fair to the little girls.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. brisa i completely agree with you because even if he was upset about it he didn't have to do that to those girls

      Delete
    2. i would be mad at the bomber

      Delete
  23. awnser for question #2 i would be shocked that they shot at a sacret place with a bomb i would protest and make the people that did get arrested also i would call them insane for killing 4 girls at a sacret place and i would make them get jail for all of there life and i would tell them you did a really bad thing

    ReplyDelete
  24. i fell relly bad for the girls that dide

    ReplyDelete
  25. wow ...thats the saddest thing i ever heard of.

    ReplyDelete
  26. i think cause of the bombing they have surcurity chekers

    ReplyDelete
  27. 2# If I was in the chruch I wouldve been scared. Because the bomb killed 4 people. Also iI would wonder why Richard Chambills would want to blow up the chruch.

    ReplyDelete
  28. question #2: i would be mad at the judge that said that robert chambliss was not guilty of murder for those four girls in the church bombing. he was clearly responsible for those girls deaths. i would love to go back in time and get into that judges head to convince him that robert should rott in jail for the rest of his life.i mean im not trying to sould rude or anything but what messed him up so bad that he would join the kkk and kill four inesent little girls and put their parents in such a stressful situation. would you do that, of course not. -bella

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you, it's not right that he did that. And those four children shouldn't of died! The punishment wasn't even close to being enough for what he did.

      Delete
  29. that was a very sad and hurtfull story

    ReplyDelete
  30. i am answering question 2 ( i would say ) why would u put those girls in a place when it wasnt time for them to go. How do u think there family's feels i bet they cryed every night wishing they could have there babies back in there arms and not put up in the sky .

    If i was one of those moms i would make sure that man got put in jail for killing my child when she was thinking about GOD but that man took that from them that was not very nice.

    ReplyDelete
  31. #2)Well i will find out who did this and not killing him but making him sufur.I felt the pain the mother got , when reading the article.Imagine just finding a shoe of a girl after the explosion.Im asking why he did this he hurt famalis.Did heknow he killed four girls or what did he know?And i agree with Craig.

    ReplyDelete
  32. # 2 ( hoe would i hear and reponse about the story) When i first herad about the bombing , i would first feel nervous if i felted that the girls died bcause that sad .
    After the arrested, i would want to to listen about Richard Chambliss i didnt relize that four girls had died . if i was there i would be disapionted in the Richrad for killing them Ladies .Richard would get the fined for $100 because i guess he was just to jelious

    ReplyDelete
  33. i am answering question#2 (how would i respond) when someone tells me about the bombing i would feel really sad cause then people would start worrying what would happen i would feel really shocked that the girls had died because they did nothing wrong but yet someone had to bomb the church and that was really wrong so now i would make the best of it

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree about the girls doing nothing to get hurt

      Delete
  34. I am answering Q.#1(members of the civil rights movement) I think that they would feel realy stressed and filed with a little less hope every single day. I can't beleive how crule they were to darker people because they were born the way they where
    Madeline Lacker

    ReplyDelete
  35. #2: I think that the people where really mad the man who bombed the the Church. I think that the 4 girls did not do any thing. They only whent to Church. The man killed the girls who did nothing. I think that he should have gone longrer to jail for the rest of his life. He got a $100 fine for dynamit. he didn't have a permit for the dynamit.

    ReplyDelete
  36. I am Anwsering question 2 I would be enraged because you don't just walk to a church and kill 4 people the walk away. i was surprised when he wasn't guilty of murder charges and only got 6 months in prision I liked it when he got life in prision he finally had justice!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree colin because if you just walk in a church and kill 4 people an just walk away and not get life in prison right away and the fine should be 1,000 dolars

      Delete
    2. i agree with you because there is no excuse for only getting 6 months in jail for bombing a church full of kids.

      Delete
  37. #2 i would first be scared and sad. i would be really sad because i would think about all of the people that died in the bombing. i would also be sad thinking about the parents who dropped there kids off there and then they hear the bombing and realise there kid or kids died. i would be scared because i would hope that the bombing wouldnt happen again.

    ReplyDelete
  38. i am doing question1 i think they felt very bad and it hurted the girls families .also those men should have went to jail for life, for what they have done.

    ReplyDelete
  39. I am answering answering question #2
    at first i would be really sad and depressed because those girls did not do anything wrong just because they were in sunday school WOW he should be in prision/jail for more than just 6 months so that is just so cruel to those four girls.

    My question for him is"why, why did you put that bomb there just why"


    ashley gonzalez

    ReplyDelete
  40. I think it made them realize that they might need to be more secrititive and made them realize how much they still had to fight.

    ReplyDelete
  41. i would have said come on thats the sixteenth church destroyed this year and would have accualy be mad that someone could be that stupid and do that

    ReplyDelete
  42. Q#2 I would be really scared and afraid of what would happen next.

    ReplyDelete
  43. 2: i would feel mad that the children died( im not sure theyre all girls :I ) i would judge him guilty and to be executed within a week for killing innocent people. the innocent people died for following what they believe and i believe thats morrowly wrong. sad face D;

    ReplyDelete
  44. why did he bomb the church and only get a $100 fine with only 6months in jail and killed 4 girls

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree with you because if i were the judge that sentenced him i would give a lot more for a fine and made him stay in jail for a lot longer time because it was very wrong to do and it shouldn't go punished with such little consequences

      Delete
    2. because back then the police were stupid and arrogent and oblivious and sometimes corrupt.

      Delete
  45. awsering # 2( how i would react ) when i would hear about the bombing ,i would feel sad for the girls who died of a selfish man .When he got arrested i would sit at the court and listen to that horrible man explain why he bombed the church .i would be mad at the judge for just giving him a fine .

    ReplyDelete
  46. i would have cried if that was my daughter

    ReplyDelete
  47. amswering quesion 2,I would feel sad that people died and some got badly injured.I think Richard should have been in jail for killing the kids and not just for the dynamite and a 100 dollar fine.If only he wasn't so dumb to bomb that church those kids wouldn't have died and that tragidy wouldn't have happened.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i know right i completely agree he should have gone to jail for, you know murder that is a huge crime, and its really sad they should have felt how other people feel about their family and friends for him murdering them with a bomb at the church, and what did the people that where injured or killed do to Richard i mean seriously. They should have really thought about it and arested him instead of charging Richard money for the bomb instead of The people and damage of property, i would know, my dad is a police man!

      Delete
  48. HIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIH
    Question #1
    The members of the Civil RIghts Movement were probably outraged about the bombing, because they were innocent, and killed for just being a diffrent color.
    HIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHI

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that they were really outraged im suprised they didnt follow a lawsuit

      Delete
    2. i agree with claire because they were really scared.

      Delete
    3. I agree that they where outraged because there where not doing any thing wronge

      Delete
  49. (im awnsering question #1)
    I think it had a big effect on the civil rights movement. I also think it was very unfair that the girls got killed at the church bombing and that Richard should have had a bigger punishment.

    ReplyDelete
  50. who on earth would do this kind of thing.the children were innocent.color does not matter.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Question#2 I Feel bad because those girls didnt deserve to die they were innocent ,I Dont Understand why he only got a few months of jail he deserves to go to prison forever because he hurt famililes and their kids

    ReplyDelete
  52. i would have made sure he had plenty of time in prision for the commity

    ReplyDelete
  53. i felt like those little girls did not died the guy should go to jail for life for haveing bombing a religious place killing four innocent girls

    ReplyDelete
  54. Question2: i fell bad for those girls because why would they kill them just because they were going to church

    ReplyDelete
  55. i fill real bad for the family they just went to church why did they have to die

    ReplyDelete
  56. #1 it woud probly flare up the movements and the roits #2 I would be sad and mad at the bomer

    ReplyDelete
  57. i think the guy should have not put the dinomite under the church and that he should go to jail for a longer time. i was surprised and shocked.

    ReplyDelete
  58. im answering #2 ( how i would feel/respond ) I would be shocked and suprised that a man would do that to the chruch and those people. i mean he hurt 14 people and killed a few kids!!! i feel like he should get a death penelty for this sin during chruch. they were beng killed for their race. i feel like it doesnt matter what race you are because we are all the same and this man is very rasist and a sinner. this is just my thought but i think most willl agree

    ReplyDelete
  59. It put pressure on them to get African Americans rights in progress.

    ReplyDelete
  60. Question #2
    If one of those children was one of my family members or anyone I would be mad because they did nothing wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  61. I agree with you because after hurting others he should have gotten a bader punishment like life on prison or the death sentence after all it was his intention to hurt others

    ReplyDelete
  62. Q #2
    i would be very sad,angry,and scared. i would be angry because the 4 children who died were very young.

    ReplyDelete
  63. #2 I would be very shocked someone would do that and be very sad that he would kill children

    ReplyDelete
  64. (awnsering question 2) If only Richard wouldn't have bombed that church the kids could have lived a long normal life and died of natural causes. He should have been sentenced to a life time in prison and been charged with a fine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  65. Question #1:I think that civil rights activists would have thought of this as a type of segregation and that like most of the non colored people in Alabama hated colored people. I am also very glad that the man who did this was captured and brought to justice.

    ReplyDelete
  66. I'm answering question two. I would have responded by trying to figure out more about who did it and why they did it and i would be angry about it because it killed four people and injured fourteen people for a total of eighteen casualties and the families of those people would feel sad and i would help them about it and people shouldn't kill other people based on their ethnicity

    ReplyDelete
  67. 2. I would be shocked, because those girls we're so young, and could have done great things.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Q1: the people of the civil rights movement probaly thought that this was segragation and that the white were against the colored.

    ReplyDelete
  69. you could tell in the story the Civil Rights Movement and others were pretty much all effected by the bombing.Except the people against segregation who just wouldn't care about the African Amreicans.Of corse the Civil Rights Movement probably felt like protesting sense their against cruelty.Along with others who beleived in equal rights at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  70. The effects about the bombing was sad and the kids that died parents was emotional because their kids died.

    ReplyDelete
  71. that they did not like there skin color

    ReplyDelete
  72. i would be sad because people would have died

    ReplyDelete
  73. I am responding to question 2 I would have been freaking out. Scared that it would happen again.

    ReplyDelete
  74. I would've responded by freaking out! It would be REALLY scary, because alot of people might not have known what was going on if they weren't at the church. I also would've been REALLY mad, because some of my "colored" friends could've been in there and they were killed only because of their skin color!!(Q#2)

    ReplyDelete
  75. question 2 .... I would have been freaking out scared it would happen again

    ReplyDelete
  76. Question#2 I would have been scared and worried that anyone I know got hurt or was affected by it

    ReplyDelete
  77. awnsering question 2 , after hearing the story i was shocked . if i heard about the news i would be scared and be spending every second after that with my family .

    ReplyDelete
  78. #2 I would have responed kind of sad,because people died and familys would feel empy without having their family member beacuse he/she would have been gone.Also stand up.Dont just know it happened do something about it so that .it wouldnt happen again

    ReplyDelete
  79. (Q#2) I would be sad for all the familys.

    ReplyDelete
  80. I am doing question.#2 I would have been veary sad if a boming happend near my house because many people could die I would be scared to because I dont want to get hurt or any of my family.

    ReplyDelete
  81. If it where me in the situation, i would be in a state of deep depression and shock. i would be sad.:(

    ReplyDelete
  82. if i where in brimingham i would have wanted to help the people who lost freinds or family members

    ReplyDelete
  83. i think it would hve made them mad. i would have writen a very strongly worded letter to the person who did that

    ReplyDelete
  84. i would feel real sad.

    ReplyDelete
  85. Question #2
    If I was in Birmingham at the time, I would have felt shocked and devastated that someone would bomb a church and kill four teen-age girls.

    ReplyDelete
  86. answering question 2, i would feel sad that people died and got injured. I also think it was unfair that richard only got a $100 fine and went to jail for only 6 months.

    ReplyDelete
  87. why was there so much hate :p

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. YUP! There was a lot of hate during the bombing i guess. There was also people being MEAN to people with a different skin color. :((( Bestieeee

      Delete
    2. I would be shocked at the bombing and would probably cry.

      Delete
  88. I think the people of the community would be sad

    ReplyDelete
  89. I am answering question 1.... I think it would have made them feel sad and mad that it happened

    ReplyDelete
  90. I agree thats what i would have done.......

    ReplyDelete
  91. I would be very sad and angry all at the same time because i dont like people dying.

    ReplyDelete
  92. question#2 I would be said because the girls didn't have to die because they were just going to church.

    ReplyDelete
  93. answering ques. #2 I would have responded....... why in the world would some want to bomb a church? the church is sopoused to be a peaceful place! people have died because of the bombing! Its just really sad!..!
    Answering ques. #1, now I think that the members were very unhappy for what the people have done to the church. and that all people have equal rights

    ReplyDelete
  94. #2- I would feel sad about the Bombing and it is not fair that they charged people $100 fine for the bombing.

    ReplyDelete